2017 Update part 4
Here is the text of a comment I have added to the Upper Hutt Library Recollect site. All statements below can be verified by source material.
In my opinion "Cruickshank's Hill" is a heritage site and should be preserved. In 1857 a water tunnel was built to take water to what was then called the the Fernground Saw Mill. In 1875 a rail tunnel was built. The rail tunnel was at a higher level than the water tunnel and crossed it near the western end of the rail tunnel. The water tunnel was replaced with a 3 ft brick culvert where the railway crossed it.
A weir in the Mungaroa River (as it was then called) directed water to the water tunnel. In 1921 it was proposed to use the water tunnel to supply a power station 200ft below on the floor of the Hutt Valley.
In 1881 the Railways Department built a dam in the water race (western side) to supply water to Upper Hutt Station via a pipe along the railway formation.
Near the western portal of the rail tunnel a bridge carried a tramway over the railway.
Both the rail tunnel and the water tunnel are extant, although the latter is silted up. It is possible that the dam in the water race still exists - I have a report of it being seen in the 1980s. It is also possible that parts of the tramway formation may exist above the rail tunnel portals provided they have not been destroyed by logging. Open sections of the water race are extant.
The entrance to the water tunnel was probably blocked when the Mangaroa Stream weir was removed and I have not located the exact location. However maps of the period narrow down the search area.
The railway formation is visible in the background so that would date the photo post 1874.
2017 Update part 3
Phyllis McNab's statement Around 1876 the same tunnel was used to bring the railway through from the Upper Hutt incline is incorrect. There were two tunnels.
2017 Update part 2
On Tuesday 14th March 2017 I visited Cruickshank's Tunnel via route 1. I made two important discoveries that help me explain the relationship between the railway tunnel, the water race to Cruickshanks's Mill and a water supply to Upper Hutt Staton.
I am waiting for some information about the Upper Hutt Station water feed before I publish my conclusions.
The next day I discovered in the National Archives two plans that may prove wrong Phyliss McNab's claim that "Around 1876 the same tunnel was used to bring the railway through from the Upper Hutt incline". I believe that the plans will prove that there were two tunnels, with the railway tunnel crossing over the water race tunnel near the western portal of the railway tunnel. Also I believe that during construction of the railway the water race was damaged and Cruickshank claimed damages. I hope that all will be confirmed when I visit the archives to view the plans.
I have received a private email about the Cruickshanks Mill water race. Here is an extract from the email:
I noticed that you had identified the brick-lined drainage tunnel running alongside the formation near the eastern end of Cruickshank's Tunnel as the original course of the water race that brought water down from Mangaroa Valley to James Cruickshank's mill. This claim was also made by J A Kelleher in his book 'Upper Hutt: The History', based on the recollection of a Phyllis McNab who lived contemporaneous with Cruickshank. Unfortunately, this claim is incorrect!
The tunnel that brought water from Mangaroa to the lake on the terrace above
Cruickshank's mill was actually an entirely separate structure, and was
excavated for Cruickshank by Henry Bannister. (A reference to Henry
Bannister as the excavator of the water tunnel can be found in Joseph
Kenneally's book 'Upper Hutt: Reflections From The Past'.)
McNab's claim about the water race is included in a Mangaroa School jubilee booklet. She wrote Around 1876 the same tunnel was used to bring the railway through from the Upper Hutt incline.
A 1915 Trentham Camp Manoevre Area map shows a dam in the Mangaroa Stream near the eastern portal of Cruickshanks Tunnel. The dam was also shown in a 1929 map. Was this the location of the water race entrance?
A photo of Cruickshanks Mill circa 1870 shows that the mill was in operation after the railway had been constructed. This suggests that the water race was operational after the railway tunnel had been built.
Construction of Railways papers in AHJR (1871) include Rochfort's report into his proposed alignment of the Silverstream to Featherston railway. He wrote "I have completed the trial line from Featherston to the Hutt Valley, choosing an exit from the bush at Mr. Cruickshank's tunnel".
Plan of Water Race showing the relationship to the railway tunnel. Details to be added after I have viewed the plan at the National Archives. May also include details of damage to the water race.
In 2016 the Upper Hutt Leader published a story which stated that the local council planned to create a public track to the tunnel along the old formation. I do not have any other information about this project.
A 1958 aerial photo of the old formation can be viewed here. The large embankment that was destroyed when the Kingsley Heights subdivision was constructed is clearly visible.
Routes to Tunnel
I first wrote this page in 2003. In May 2016, following receipt of new information and in possession of a gps enabled phone, I visited the tunnel again. I discovered that there are now two mud-free routes to the tunnel.
The journey involves an uphill climb. It does NOT involve walking through any mud. The instructions for getting to the tunnel are:
- Go through the subway at the end of Cruickshanks Road.
- Turn hard left and follow the track.
That is all there is to it!
Cruickshanks Road to west portal of tunnel is a gpx file that can be opened in google earth.
Walk along the old formation from the end of King Charles Drive in Kingsley Height to the tunnel. I prefer this route because the 19th century cuttings and embankments can be studied. Also the grade is easy. The distance is 1.16km with an easy walking time of 30 minutes one way. There are several locations where trains on the new formation can be photographed.
west portal of tunnel to Kingsley Heights is a gpx file that can be opened in google earth.
- The gps lost signal at the west tunnel portal.
- About 200m from King Charles Drive the track deviated from the formation.
- For more information about Cruickshanks Mill and the water race go to this geocaching page.
Old Upper Hutt - Featherston Route
Railway Routes. Old and new rail routes between Upper Hutt and Featherston. The Rimutaka Deviation opened in 1955.
Artifact seen on the old formation.
The Tracks To Cruickshanks Tunnel
A 2016 Photo
Photographed from the old formation train 1604 crosses the Cruickshanks Road overbridge (left). The Cannon Point Trig (officially 7503 Upper Hutt No 2) is in the background. The photographer is about 220m from the west portal of Cruickshanks Tunnel.
The Old Alignment
The upper image was photographed from the track up to Cannon Point Trig (officially 7503 Upper Hutt No 2). The dots mark the old formation. A logging train is descending the grade to Upper Hutt on the new 1955 alignment.
The Google Earth image shows the old route in plan view.
These photos were taken in 2003. Captions refer to the Route 1 from Cruickshanks Road.
I am trying to find a location to get some better photos.
The Rimutaka Deviation climbs on a grade of 1 in 70 (right to left) to the Mangaroa Tunnel. The subway under the railway is at the end of Cruickshank Road.
2016 comment: I think that the Cruickshanks tunnel is to the left of the photo. The comment on the photo is probably meaningless.
I believe that the railway formation is in a cutting behind the ridge on the right.
2016 comment: The tunnel location may be correct. The "cutting" comment may be wrong.
A four arm telegraph pole is extant in the hills. There is a distinct line between regenerating bush and gorse - is this the alignment?
2016 comment: The pole is no longer visible from the track up to the tunnel. It can be seen from the bottom of the zig zag to Cannon Point. It appears to below the formation. I wonder if it is a P&T pole on the old mainline to the Wairarapa?.
Continue straight ahead past the two blazed trees. Keep towards the right - do not be tempted to turn left and head straight up the ridge. For a good view of the telegraph pole turn right between the blazed trees and proceed to K.
2016 comment: The pole is no longer visible.
The entrance to a drainage tunnel which runs parallel to the portal cutting. The tunnel is about 38 paces (say 30m) long. I suspect that once it was completely bricked up as just behind the camera is a small drain in the track bed. The tunnel is large enough to walk through but a stick poked into the mud suggests that that would not be wise. Looking towards Upper Hutt.
2016 comment: This is the water race to Cruickshank's Mill.
Looking along the formation towards Upper Hutt. The drainage tunnel is centre right. After a short distance the track becomes almost impassable - a slasher would be essential if an attempt was made to walk to the Kingsley Heights subdivision, where an embankment has been destroyed.
2016 comment: It is an easy walk along the old formation to King Charles Drive. A slasher is not required.
The Upper Hutt portal of Cruickshanks Tunnel photographed from the approach cutting.
The cross-section of Cruickshanks Tunnel. Looking towards Mangaroa Valley.
Remains of the bridge over the Mangaroa River. See photos on pages 95 & 97 in A Line Of Railway (W N Cameron). The tunnel is behind the camera but is not visible from this location because of blackberry.
2016 comment: I could not see the bridge remains.
Bridge piles in the Mangaroa River. Looking towards the tunnel.
2016 comment: I could not see the bridge remains.
This section was written in 2003 before the age of Google Maps, Google Earth and phones with GPS. I have retained it for the record but it is no longer essential to finding the tunel.
The diagram is based on three site visits at the end of April 2003. I took some compass bearings but did not use any other survey instrument apart from the Mk 1 Eyeball. The location of the access track is approximate only. Cruickshanks tunnel was on the electronic map I extracted from NZTopo Online and is correctly aligned relative to Flux Road in the Mangaroa Valley, so its location should be correct.
S Walk under subway and follow the track. Two short sections are knee deep in mud and boots are essential.
A The track goes down a small drop. Directly ahead is a stream. This may be the drainage stream. I must check. Turn right and go back up.
B A telegraph pole can be seen on the hill. Note the line between regenerating bush and gorse - is this the alignment? Must check that stream crosses track here.
C Arrive at two blazed trees. Continue straight ahead, sidling around the ridge. Keep to the right - do not be tempted to go straight up the ridge.
D Look to the right across a small gully. A blaze can be seen on a tree on the far side (E).
E Follow the track up hill past the blaze.
N Sidle around the ridge. Eventually a stream will be seen on the right. This is the drainage stream. The stream exits from a channel about a metre deep.
F The portal of a drainage tunnel will be seen on the right. Turn right immediately above the portal. Follow the track for a short distance down and then drop down onto the rail formation. Turn left and Voila!!!
G Cruickshanks Tunnel.
H Remains of bridge over Mangaroa stream. Access track is through blackberry to the right (south) of rail centre line. Turn left at river.
I Remains of barbed wire fence and gate. Walk up ridge from drainage tunnel portal to get to it.
J Brick lined pit (three paces square) with pipes in it at edge of formation. A channel goes a short distance down to what appears to be a levelled area.
The alignment from Cruickshanks Tunnel to Upper Hutt shown above is approximate. My sources are Inch to the Mile topographical map NZMS1 N161 (1974) and aerial photographs from the Upper Hutt City Council online Rates Database. Click here for an aerial photograph. The alignment is not visible from the ground. Just north of Upper Hutt, an embankment which was was once visible from the main road has been destroyed by subdivision earthworks.
NZTopoOnline, extracted April 2003, Crown Copyright Reserved.
K Turn right (going up) between the two blazed trees (C) and follow the track down. It crosses the drainage stream and then turns left and goes back up, from where there is a good view of the telegraph pole. Maybe it would be possible to get to the pole from here? The pole seems very close.
L Four arm telegraph pole (approximate location).
M Railway formation. Is this a cutting? (Approximate location of formation).
T Trig - Not shown on inch to mile or 1 in 50,000 topo maps.
GPS Coordinates In 2008 I visited the tunnel with a GPS receiver. On the Upper Hutt side tall trees made reception difficult. However I was able to obtain the coordinates of the Maymorn portal:
NZMG N 6007255 E 2686156
WGS84 (Google Earth) S 41 deg 07' 21" S 175 deg 05' 53"
Last Updated: Thursday 16h March 2017